Retail and Napa Pipe

Why more retail at Napa Pipe is a mistake

A major new wrinkle to the Napa Pipe plan is the introdution of Costco as a possible tenant there, along with the proposed residential and other components. In order to really understand the impact, it is necessary to examine the overall retail situation in Napa as a whole.

One of the issues with the jail downtown has been the fact that downtown Napa already has too much of a retail footprint--just look at the empty storefronts. Opening up another large space to retail if the jail leaves will only add to that problem. If you want new stores downtown, for which there is widespread support, you need to have sufficient customers as a base to support them.

This is why Wal Mart told American Canyon they wouldn't come in until they had developed more nearby residential, so American Canyon did so. Although I haven't asked him, this has to be a major reason why it is taking Todd Zapolski so long to get tenants for the Shops in Napa, formerly the Town Center.

That is why the downtown merchants have said they would like to see another one thousand hotel rooms downtown. Those are customers for retail stores.

I have supported the downtown plan in Napa and especially would like  to see more housing built there. Besides providing customers to the downtown area, people who live there could theoretically walk to work if they work downtown, thus helping with the traffic issue. Those units would be expensive but hopefully some of the workers could afford them.

Even though Costco will be close to town, it is still a satellite area that will require everyone to get in their cars and go there. At least with downtown you have a chance to build it as a walkable community and have some people go via bicycles or public transit. This is what the downtown plan calls for.

Right now we don't have enough customers to support the retail we already have, enough to please the business owners at least. If we add a Costco without adding significant population, that is going to take business away from someone else. Look at the items Costco sells, wine, food, clothing, furniture, etc and you are going to see a decrease in sales at other stores who sell these items.

You are also going to see reduced tax collections in the other stores. This effect may be ameliorated by bringing some business back to Napa that goes to other towns, or by bringing some people in from other towns, but the likelihood is that Costco will impact the two Wal Marts and Safeway's that are in Napa County, perhaps even putting someone out of business. Gillwoods mentioned that increased competition from all the new restaurants is part of the reason they are closing.  

The end result could be another black spot of emptiness in a business district, while people drive out of downtown to shop as a replacement.

The answer for the business community is to constantly push for growth in order to provide new customers, either growth of tourism or growth of residents. In probably 99% of places that wouldn't be a problem, it would be seen as succeeding. In Napa some see it as success and traditionally most have opposed it.  We are in an economic set up where we need to constantly grow just to stay even.

The plan to develop Napa Pipe with a Costco, plus all the downtown stores, Gasser, the St. Regis Hotel near Stanley Ranch, plus the new one thousand hotel rooms downtown are all going to need employees, lots of them, and that is just some of the planned growth.

Right now there is not a realistic plan in Napa to handle the traffic that much growth would generate. The Costco itself, like the Wal Mart in American Canyon, will generate a lot of traffic.  Some don't seem  really concerned about that, perhaps some don't care, perhaps some just figure we will just muddle through.  But we should care because it will have a dramatic effect on our quality of life.

What typically happens in communities like this is growth occurs until there is gridlock, and then it stops and traffic barely moves, it slugs along. Growth stops because no business wants to build in that environment, and that is finally how growth is controlled.

I am hopeful that we can find a plan to manage this and cap off the growth before we get to that point. Growth is going to cap off anyway, why not do it in a  way that retains a better quality of life for the local residents?

As I was about to post this article, I saw today's announcement from the County and City of Napa, and it appears that this Napa Pipe plan may be an inevitability. What started out as widespread community opposition to Napa Pipe has been worn down by years of fighting and constantly shifting plans. And $70 million dollars worth of effort by the developer.

For me it is not so much about this particular project, but the overall growth in Napa that is going on. Napa Pipe will generate a lot of growth beyond itself, and for those opposed like myself it was a big step forward into turning Napa yet further away from a smaller farming community into a big tourist town.

Are we really going to like that better? I doubt it.

Ironically, our success appears to be destroying the very thing people wanted to move here for, the small town farming atmosphere and sense of community. We will see, unless there is a big revolt from the community that is the path we are on and where we are going to end up, quicker than you think.  

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Michael Haley November 20, 2012 at 11:43 PM
thanks vocal!
Louisa Hufstader November 20, 2012 at 11:57 PM
Congrats, Michael, on joining the Park and open Space District board (sorry I called it a commission by mistake at first!) http://napavalley.patch.com/articles/michael-haley-joins-county-park-commission
Catherine George November 21, 2012 at 05:20 AM
Well said, Alex, thanks!
Marissa Roehrs December 06, 2012 at 08:16 PM
I would love to see Costco here! Currently I have to leave town to do shopping and any holiday shopping and everyone I know does the same. We have to go to Fairfield or Concord or Vallejo. We need more housing but it needs to be affordable! Many friends of mine who grew up in Napa can't afford to stay here so they go to American Canyon or leave the area completely. It's a difficult situation but I feel Napa needs to grow...bigger businesses, more affordable house etc.
Michael Haley December 07, 2012 at 02:05 AM
Marissa, thanks for checking in and making your comment. The problem as I see it is that if we continue the growth path we are on it is going to end up taking you just as long to drive to Napa Pipe's Costco as it does now to the one in Vallejo or Fairfield. We cannot keep growing as you suggest without becoming as stuffed full of traffic as all the other towns like Walnut Creek and Concord that go through a growth pattern like that. Napa's charm and one of the main reasons I love living here is that it is a small close knit community. Continual large developments like that will ruin that. Sometimes we have to give up one thing to get something else. We cannot be all things to all people.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »